A Crafts Community For Craft Ideas & DIY Projects - Craftster.org
Help | About | Contact | Press | Advertise | Terms | Site Map
Welcome, Guest.
Please login or register.
Random Tip: Need help? Click the HELP link at the top of the screen to read the docs or ask at the Help Desk.
Total Members: 296,620
Currently Running With Scissors:
701 Guests and 27 Users
Home Craftster Community Crafting Articles Craft Tutorials My Craftster Crafting Calendar City Guides Craft Shop


Pages: [1]
Jump to page:
  Show Images Only     Send this topic  |  Print  |  Bookmark  
Topic: Crochet vs Knitting - yarn usage  (Read 732 times)
Tags for this thread:  Add new tag
Share the love... Pin it Submit to reddit add to Wists
1+
 
dofnup
Offline Offline

Posts: 53
Joined: 14-Sep-2006

The eternal search for the perfect shrug >_>


View Profile WWW
« on: March 31, 2008 08:22:38 AM »

Hello fellow Craftsters!

I didn't know if I should post this topic on the Crochet board or the Knitting board, but I had to choose one so here I am.

I recently bought $50 worth of yarn to make myself a laptop bag based on this pattern

http://www.craftster.org/forum/index.php?topic=190912.0,

and $50 is a LOT of money for me. I started crocheting it because I figured it would be sturdier with crochet stitches (can't felt it since it's all acrylic), but I'm halfway through my yarn and NOT close to the halfway mark of the bag. I refue on principle to go out and buy another $50 of yarn, so I can have a $100 laptop bag. $100 for a laptop bag? I might as well use the yarn for something else and just BUY a laptop bag.  Undecided

I've heard that crocheting uses up 3x more yarn than knitting, so I'm seriously considering frogging and knitting it instead ... does anyone have any experience in the difference of yarn usage between crocheting and knitting that can help me figure out if the effort will be worth it or not?  Huh

Thanks bunches in advance!  Grin
THIS ROCKS   Logged

Knitting goals: Learn - Make Shrug - Cables - Make Fingerless Gloves - Lace
Crochet goals: Learn - Make Amigurumi! - STARGHAN! - Amigurumi for Everyone @ Xmas
My FO's: http://picasaweb.google.com/dofnup/FOS
... or on Ravelry!
Flia
Purple butterfly
Offline Offline

Posts: 192
Joined: 31-Mar-2007

Yarn, pearls, thread, pearls, yarn, yarn, yarn


View Profile WWW
« Reply #1 on: March 31, 2008 08:27:31 AM »

You're right, knitting is much less yarn consuming, so I'd go ahead and frog if I were you.
THIS ROCKS   Logged

soozeq
« Reply #2 on: March 31, 2008 08:44:14 AM »

I'm not sure if crochet uses 3 times more yarn, or 1/3 or 1/2 more, but it definitely uses more. I picked up a crocheted scarf at the thrift store for $1, wasn't especially long, but using large needles, I knit an elbow length capelet/shawl from it all.
THIS ROCKS   Logged

sue
elijor
« Reply #3 on: April 01, 2008 07:00:42 AM »

Before you frog - if you haven't already that is - you might want to try out a couple of different stitches to see what uses more yarn. (knit a swatch with a specific amount of yarn and seee which is bigger or do a couple of swatches the same size and see which uses more yarn) I would guess that since you are doing a laptop bag it will need to be knit with a very sturdy stitch that will not stretch under the weight of the laptop. The best one that comes to mind would be the Linen Stitch which uses more yarn than plain old garter or stockinette. Most stitches that are sturdy will involve some sort of "slip stitch" and they use more yarn.

On the other hand if you can sew - even just a little - you could use garter or stockinette and line the bag with a sturdy fabric. Just make sure you use Linen stitch or something like that for the handle.
THIS ROCKS   Logged
dofnup
Offline Offline

Posts: 53
Joined: 14-Sep-2006

The eternal search for the perfect shrug >_>


View Profile WWW
« Reply #4 on: April 01, 2008 03:25:04 PM »

Yeah, I think lining it is going to be the best solution ... that way, if needed, I can use an "airier" stitch to conserve yarn ... blah!
THIS ROCKS   Logged

Knitting goals: Learn - Make Shrug - Cables - Make Fingerless Gloves - Lace
Crochet goals: Learn - Make Amigurumi! - STARGHAN! - Amigurumi for Everyone @ Xmas
My FO's: http://picasaweb.google.com/dofnup/FOS
... or on Ravelry!
Lothruin
Friend of Craftster Friend of Craftster

Offline Offline

Posts: 4643
Joined: 23-Jan-2004

I eat seakittens.


View Profile WWW available for personal swaps
« Reply #5 on: April 02, 2008 08:34:33 AM »

Just for future reference:

Although it depends entirely on which knit stitches you are comparing with which crochet stitches, a good basis for comparison is that crochet uses 30% more yarn.  (Not 3x more, or else I'd be totally and completely broke from all those years of crocheting and not knitting. Cheesy

I would think that unless you were felting it, I'd want it lined no matter which stitch, knitting or crochet, got used.  Eventually any of them would tend to stretch with the weight of the laptop.  So I would not worry about how sturdy the stitch is, I'd use whatever you have yarn for.
THIS ROCKS   Logged

Find craft patterns, supplies and humor at Lothruin.com!

Find me on Ravelry as Lothruin!
dofnup
Offline Offline

Posts: 53
Joined: 14-Sep-2006

The eternal search for the perfect shrug >_>


View Profile WWW
« Reply #6 on: April 02, 2008 10:54:02 AM »

Excellent advice! I guess I was a little off on the yarn usage ... I knew there was a "3" involved!  Cheesy

Guess I start frogging tonight!
THIS ROCKS   Logged

Knitting goals: Learn - Make Shrug - Cables - Make Fingerless Gloves - Lace
Crochet goals: Learn - Make Amigurumi! - STARGHAN! - Amigurumi for Everyone @ Xmas
My FO's: http://picasaweb.google.com/dofnup/FOS
... or on Ravelry!
Threads you might like:
Pages: [1] Jump to page:
  Send this topic  |  Print  |  Bookmark  
 
Jump to:  



only results with images
include swap threads
advanced search



your ad could be here!

How-To Videos
How to Buy Iron On Patches
How to Design T-shirts with Iron On Patches
How to Buy Iron On Letters
How to Iron On Fabric and Rhinestone Letters
How to Design Iron On Transfers for T-shirts
Latest Blog Articles
Winner of Craft Challenge #100-Pottermouth
July 23, 2014 Featured Projects
Tute Tuesday: Fabric and Felt Bird Ornament

Comparison Shopping




Support Craftster
Become a
Friend of Craftster

Buy Craftster Swag
Buy Craft Supplies
Comparison Shopping

Craftster heartily thanks the following peeps...
Moderators

Follow Craftster...






Powered by MySQL Powered by PHP Powered by SMF 1.1.11 | SMF © 2006-2009, Simple Machines LLC
SimplePortal 2.3.5 © 2008-2012, SimplePortal
Valid XHTML 1.0! Valid CSS!

Copyright ©2003-2014, Craftster.org an Internet Brands company.