Now this is not technically a shower gift, because it's for my own baby, but fits well here.
I made a cover for a "boppy" style pillow that I picked up at Jo-Ann's. I used the pattern on the pillow's package. I'm pretty pleased with how it turned out. And cheap! The pillow was only $10 on sale, and then I just got some cheap-o orange fabric to go with my stash Ikea stuff. Add a zipper, and done!
Thanks for looking!