I'm so excited that there are other Lonely Island Lvrs out there! Here is the stencil I used for any of your Andy Samberg crafting needs. (It would be super-secksy to make a pillow!) Thanks again for all your awesome feedback. Much love!
Oh... I'm horrible at checking my own posts and didn't realize I'm a total jerk and didn't clarify some questions! I made the buttons with a 1" button maker (yay e-bay!). The "I wonder if people suspect that I'm a wolf" is from the Lonely Island song "Zanzabar" (kickin it ol' skool tli) and the silf one is actually a shirt from Busted Tees, just as an homage to how Andy <3's sandwiches!