It appears that I have run afoul of a really frustrating loophole in the new swapper requirements. Specifically #3, “If you have never swapped on Craftster before, you can only sign up for ONE swap to start out with. Then when you complete that swap and get Positive Feedback, you can sign up for as many others as you want.”
Now, I signed up for the ongoing fabric swap as my first swap because it looked easy, a great way to get my feet wet and well, I’m a fabric addict. Figuring that since I obviously couldn’t get a positive feedback for an ongoing swap, perhaps I’d be allowed to participate in another small one, I asked to join one to both participate and get my positive in a timely manner. After a number of PMs being tossed back and forth it’s come clear that I really should not have joined an ongoing swap as my first one.
And this is where my frustration and issue comes into effect. It’s not made clear that joining an ongoing swap as a new swapper is a bad idea. Neither is it clear that gaining a positive in an ongoing means leaving the swap permanently if it’s underway. My impressions were that I’d join the ongoing fabric swap, swap with someone, get my positive and then continue in the fabric swap and try out other swaps as well. Instead I am faced with leaving and becoming unable to rejoin a swap that I enjoy so that I can fulfill the requirements of being a swapper.
Now, I have no complaint with the new swapper requirements. I think they’re smart and wise, and to paraphrase my fiancé, I know I won’t flake, but nobody else does. I just feel that there’s a loophole between the positive feedback requirement and the ability to join ongoing swaps. Even clarification within the Organized Swaps help page noting that joining an ongoing could be a problem would be helpful. Or perhaps the addition of another feedback option of “In Progress - Positive” would work as well.
Personally I've decided to stay in the fabric swap, it's where I want to be. But the entire experience of dealing with this loophole has definitely affected my interest in being a swapper in the long term, and as such, I thought it an important issue to raise.
Thanks.














)












