all right, this is going to seem waaay out in the boonies for all you city folk (lol) but if anyone's in the wisconsin dells area:
there are two st vincents. one is right off the strip and it is never good. the other is across the street from zinke's a couple blocks from the strip. this one's worth a try.
in reedsburg, 15 miles away, there are two. there's a st vincents right on main st that's pretty good and a thrift store run by the hospital called riverview thrift store. this is on alexander ave, i think?
in baraboo, 10 or so miles away, is my FAVORITE thrift store, st vincent de paul. god i cannot remember street names for the life of me right now, but it is right down the street from the pool and the skate park, down the street from the square. there is also a nice yarn shop right on the square.
in sauk city, 30 minutes from madison, there is a nice st vincents off highway P. they're usually a little pricey, but they've got great furniture, fabrics, and craft supplies.