Here is what I ended up doing. They sell these jars in different color lids at World Market for $.99 each. I've made so many jars of these toothpicks now! I made a set of cinnamon, orange cream, and lemon for my husband and his twin brother for their birthday. I made a set of peppermint, butterscotch, and tangerine for my dad and my father-in-law for their birthdays. Last night I made a batch of cinnamon ones for my mom. I used half of the little bottles of cinnamon, and full bottles of the other flavors in the jars.
The flavor oils were hard to find locally, but I luckily found some. I asked someone as rosauers (local grocery store) and she told me that this is going to sound weird but to ask at the pharmacy. They can order them and they are in the next day. There are so many flavors to choose for. They are $.99 each for those really tiny bottles of flavor oil. I guess they had to move them back to the pharmacy because kids were buying the cinnamon one and burning their mouths and daring each other to do the same. Teachers and parents called and told them to sell it behind the counter. Strange, huh?