And actually, I thought she knew I was a Wiccan. Apparently she just thought I was weird or something. -_-
My bet is that this was more disturbing to your mom than to you, as she probably realized that she knew even less
about you than she realized. Parents are often in a constant state of catch-up with their kids for the last few years before they go their separate ways!
It's sort of the opposite to the experience of many gay people when they finally get up enough courage to come out to their parents, only to have Mom say "Oh I know, sweetie. We were wondering when you were going to tell us!" People see what they expect to see, and anything else has to be pointed out to them, sometimes more than once.
Cake mix cookies?? Who knew? This is why Craftster is so useful!