FYI, St Theresa Textile Trove relocated from Main Street in OTR to Hamilton Avenue in College Hill a few years ago. It is across from Goody's, on the same block as LaRosas.http://www.sttheresatextile.com/store.htm
I just discovered this shop recently and recommend a visit! The shop is not easily found by googling; I just happened to run across a link from another website. I am trying to tell other crafters, because it is quite a unique shop and I want to be sure Cinicnnatians know there are some independent fabric sources. I had not found any local and had been ordering from etsy and other sites.
The shop has a nice selections of oilcloth, Japanese cottons, batiks, African tiedye and a huge selection of beads. There is also a selection of Amy Butler, Tina Givens, Joel Dewberry and some other designers. There are baskets full of fat quarters, a nice way to try new fabrics and patterns. The website has a nice catalog of fabric selections. The shop also offers some sewing and beading classes, although I have not tried them yet.