I made a Mr. Hat too!
I followed the basic pattern by BlueAndRedCows, but I pretty much had to wing it because I was using a different weight of yarn and needle size. Plus I knit it flat, because I couldn't find my DPNs, and the seaming was a b*tch, let me tell you. I made it for a friend from work, but my sister fell in love with it, and now I might have to make another one. (Which leads me to another point, wouldn't Mr. Hat mittens be fun?)
Here he is in all his glory.