I was thinking about getting a second hole pierced and doing that, but do you think it would look weird since my holes are so big?
Background: I actually got a second hole above my "normal" sized holes and started stretching those, because I wanted to start stretching, but I wanted to hang onto the option of normal earrings. I got all the way to a 4g before I realized that I pay wayyy more attention to the stretched holes and tend to just match my studs to whatever I was wearing as plugs, so I started stertching my bottom holes too. I plan on going to a 0.
I work at a pretty conservative sports camp every summer, and I had 8g there last year, but you can never tell unless you're looking for them, so I've been worried about going back with my larger holes. One plan I've come up with is to buy a set of these: http://www.bodyartforms.com/productdetails.asp?ProductID=1768
The reviews sound pretty good, and from what I hear, you can poke studs through them, since the construction is basically hollow with the thinner silicone over one end. I wish I could tell you more about them, but I'm waiting to get to that size before I start burning through my ear cash. Also, as an almost-shameless plug (HA), Bodyartforms is my favorite jewelry store on the entire internet, and I have nothing but good to say about them.
ANYWAY, point is, I've heard of people using silicone plugs as "adapters" for standard earrings, but I haven't tried it myself.