Well, I finished. I am not happy with it. It was a lot of work and it is a poor fit, although at least it fits. I think it is the shape. It is very bunchy in some places. If I were to knit it over again (which I am not), I would not do the reverse stockinette, too messy looking. I can see all of the decrease/increase spots. Perhaps that is my lack of knitting skill. I also would knit one size smaller. I want to frog it but I have no idea what to knit with the yarn ( which is knitpick sierra in cranberry color.) It was a learning experience. I did my first cables on this project, which came out great. This was also my first time successfully picking up stitches.