I want the alliance one. And come on people, we're not even in the game right now... Just because you can't control yourselves and respect one another on the game, I'd figure we could in the crafting community. I'd say A+ on the hats, but D on the attitudes.
I didn't see any disrespectful comments... it's natural for players to show their faction pride (in a nice way here!). Though I agree with your second post, there's nothing more frustrating than being camped by some <insert not so nice name here> with too much time on their hands while you're just trying to quest! I played on a PVP server for four years (I've played since just a few months after WoW launched) and just switched to an RP server a few months ago, and let me tell you, it makes the leveling process -much- more enjoyable. I highly recommend leaving a PVP server for a PVE/RP server if you're not a world PVP liker. It really makes all the difference.
I love these hats! *Plans one for Paladin fiance for christmas....*